Skip to main content

Social Media

  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • English
  • Français

Login/Register

  • Login
  • Register
  • License Information
    • CRKN Licensing Principles
    • Model License
    • The Banding System
    • Stakeholder Alignment Group
    • License Negotiations
    • Negotiation Outcomes
      • Open Access Publishing
      • Invoicing Schedule
    • Directories
    • Assessment Guidelines for Open Access Publishers
  • Heritage Content
    • Canadiana Collections
      • What’s New in the Collections
      • Navigating the Collections
      • Canadiana Citation Guide
      • Canadiana Infrastructure Updates
      • Canadiana Collections Metadata
      • Usage Reports
      • Rights Statement Project
      • History of Canadiana
    • Digitization
      • Digitization Services
      • Digitization Projects
      • Clark Wilson LLP Memo on the Acquisition and Use of Commercial Microfilm
    • Preservation and Access
      • Trustworthy Digital Repository
    • Digital Heritage Content and Preservation Listserv
    • Canadian National Digital Heritage Index
  • Tools and Services
    • CRKN Open Access Journals List
    • Foreign Exchange Service
    • Publication Data Report
    • Unsub
    • Journal Value Analytics
    • The Big Deal Toolkit
    • Institutional Mobilization Toolkit
    • Perpetual Access Rights Reports (Serials)
  • Projects and Collaborations
    • Journal Usage Project
    • Érudit Partnership & Coalition Publica
    • SCOAP³
    • NISO Membership
    • COUNTER
    • FMD
    • CC-PLUS
    • DataCite Canada Consortium
      • DataCite Canada Consortium - Member FAQ
    • ORCID Canada
      • About ORCID-CA
      • Benefits of ORCID-CA Membership
      • Join ORCID-CA
      • Persistent Identifier (PID) Governance
      • ORCID-CA FAQ
  • Publishers
  • News and Events
    • News
    • Events
    • CRKN Conference
      • 2022 CRKN Conference
      • 2021 CRKN Virtual Conference
      • 2020 CRKN Virtual Conference
      • 2019 CRKN Conference
      • Code of Conduct
  • About CRKN
    • Board of Directors
    • Members
      • Associate Membership
    • Strategic Plan
      • Strategic Plan 2019-2024
    • Committees
      • Executive Committee
      • Finance and Audit Committee
      • Content Strategy Committee
      • Knowledge Base Entitlements Sub-Committee
      • Preservation and Access Committee
        • Canadiana Content Sub-Committee
        • Platform Technical Sub-Committee
      • Conference Planning Committee
      • Task Groups
      • CRKN Researcher Council
    • Annual Report
    • Staff
    • Careers
    • History of CRKN
    • Ron MacDonald Service Award

Main navigation

  • License Information
  • Heritage Content
  • Tools and Services
  • Projects and Collaborations
  • Publishers
  • News and Events
  • About CRKN
Menu
Home

Assessment Guidelines for Open Access Publishers

The Content Strategy Committee (CSC) arrived at the Assessment Guidelines for Open Access Publishers through a consultation with the CRKN membership, the results of which were presented to and supported by members at the 2021 Conference. These are meant to be guiding principles that the CSC may use in assessing whether proposals from vendors and publishers meet with the CRKN membership’s stated goals and objectives with respect to supporting open access. We have purposefully not assigned any weighting to the criteria as the CSC is better positioned to have as much latitude as possible in assessing the offers it receives from providers. Therefore, there is not an expectation that each provider will meet every criterion.

Financial Sustainability

When evaluating open access resources or models from vendors or publishers, CRKN will consider the financial sustainability of the entity offering the resource. CRKN may consider the vendor’s ability to provide transparency through financial statements or other information that speaks to its financial health. Prospective vendors must also demonstrate commitment to and sustainability of their open access models and offer transparency in terms of the sources of funding that support that sustainability. Additionally, the origin and nature of funding sources and the vendor’s status as a for-profit or not-for-profit entity might be
considered.

  • Provider is transparent with financial statements
  • Provider does not charge, or provides a discount on Article Processing Charges (APCs)
  • Provider is non-profit
  • Provider is established (i.e., has a proven publication record and reputation)

Academic Quality

When evaluating offers, CRKN will consider the academic quality of the resource. Academic quality can be measured in traditional ways but should also not exclude resources that fall outside of traditional conceptions of academic work. Indications of a commitment to ethical editorial practices, cogent mission statements, and a demonstrated focus on equity, diversity, inclusion, and accessibility (EDIA) issues are critical. Academic quality could be measured through other lenses, such as EDIA, Indigenous ways of knowing, or other facets required to support equity and inclusion. Preference may be given to researcher/academy-led organizations and providers.

  • Provider demonstrates commitment to ethical editorial practices and research integrity, e.g. through membership in OASPA (Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association) and/or COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics), indexing in DOAJ (Directory of Open Access Journals), clear editorial policies posted on website, etc.
  • Provider demonstrates commitment to being mission-driven and/or researcher-focused
  • Provider demonstrates commitment to EDIA issues
  • Provider is a scholarly society or researcher/academy-led

Operations

When evaluating offers, CRKN will also take into account evidence of good operational practice on the part of the provider. This could take many forms, including, but not limited to, the use of open licenses (e.g., Creative Commons) the establishment of a platform that is interoperable, contains high quality metadata, provides robust data (e.g., usage, publishing) and is usable, and that has established a comprehensive preservation strategy.

  • Provider’s platform is interoperable, discoverable, and usable
  • Provider uses open licenses (e.g., Creative Commons)
  • Provider offers APC discount
  • Provider is based in Canada
  • Provider has a preservation strategy (e.g., is a participant of Portico or LOCKSS)
  • Provider’s content is indexed in OA abstracting and indexing (A&I) services (e.g., DOAJ, etc.)
  • Provider reports article-level metadata in compliance with accepted industry standards (e.g. OpenCitations, OpenAIRE)

Related Documents

Assessment Guidelines for Open Access Publishers

License Menu

  • CRKN Licensing Principles
  • Model License
  • The Banding System
  • Stakeholder Alignment Group
  • License Negotiations
  • Negotiation Outcomes
    • Open Access Publishing
    • Invoicing Schedule
  • Directories
  • Assessment Guidelines for Open Access Publishers
Footer Logo

Canadian Research Knowledge Network

1309 Carling Ave PO Box 35155 Westgate Ottawa, ON K1Z 1A2 t. 613.907.7040

Policy Menu

  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility Policy
  • Sitemap
© 2013 - 2023 Canadian Research Knowledge Network

Footer menu

  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter Sign Up

Partner Menu

  • Canadiana
  • CNDHI
  • License Information
    • CRKN Licensing Principles
    • Model License
    • The Banding System
    • Stakeholder Alignment Group
    • License Negotiations
    • Negotiation Outcomes
      • Open Access Publishing
      • Invoicing Schedule
    • Directories
    • Assessment Guidelines for Open Access Publishers
  • Heritage Content
    • Canadiana Collections
      • What’s New in the Collections
      • Navigating the Collections
      • Canadiana Citation Guide
      • Canadiana Infrastructure Updates
      • Canadiana Collections Metadata
      • Usage Reports
      • Rights Statement Project
      • History of Canadiana
    • Digitization
      • Digitization Services
      • Digitization Projects
      • Clark Wilson LLP Memo on the Acquisition and Use of Commercial Microfilm
    • Preservation and Access
      • Trustworthy Digital Repository
    • Digital Heritage Content and Preservation Listserv
    • Canadian National Digital Heritage Index
  • Tools and Services
    • CRKN Open Access Journals List
    • Foreign Exchange Service
    • Publication Data Report
    • Unsub
    • Journal Value Analytics
    • The Big Deal Toolkit
    • Institutional Mobilization Toolkit
    • Perpetual Access Rights Reports (Serials)
  • Projects and Collaborations
    • Journal Usage Project
    • Érudit Partnership & Coalition Publica
    • SCOAP³
    • NISO Membership
    • COUNTER
    • FMD
    • CC-PLUS
    • DataCite Canada Consortium
      • DataCite Canada Consortium - Member FAQ
    • ORCID Canada
      • About ORCID-CA
      • Benefits of ORCID-CA Membership
      • Join ORCID-CA
      • Persistent Identifier (PID) Governance
      • ORCID-CA FAQ
  • Publishers
  • News and Events
    • News
    • Events
    • CRKN Conference
      • 2022 CRKN Conference
      • 2021 CRKN Virtual Conference
      • 2020 CRKN Virtual Conference
      • 2019 CRKN Conference
      • Code of Conduct
  • About CRKN
    • Board of Directors
    • Members
      • Associate Membership
    • Strategic Plan
      • Strategic Plan 2019-2024
    • Committees
      • Executive Committee
      • Finance and Audit Committee
      • Content Strategy Committee
      • Knowledge Base Entitlements Sub-Committee
      • Preservation and Access Committee
        • Canadiana Content Sub-Committee
        • Platform Technical Sub-Committee
      • Conference Planning Committee
      • Task Groups
      • CRKN Researcher Council
    • Annual Report
    • Staff
    • Careers
    • History of CRKN
    • Ron MacDonald Service Award