Baking a Recipe from the Past: Testing New Features in Canadiana

By: Mélanie Plante, Communications Coordinator
https://doi.org/10.82389/efty-qf23
Fall is apple season, making it the perfect time to look for an apple-inspired recipe. But instead of turning to a modern cookbook, why not look to the past?
To find a recipe, I turned to the newly launched Canadiana beta platform. The enhancements on the platform offer an updated way to search and explore Canadiana’s digitized collections, making it even easier to uncover historical documents from books and newspapers to unexpected glimpses into everyday life.
Searching the Canadiana Beta
The search started on the homepage of the Canadiana beta platform, where I used the Canadiana Collection search bar to look for “apple pie.”
The results brought up thousands of items from Canadiana’s digitized collections. Like on the legacy Canadiana platform, pages including exact matches for search terms are featured in each search result. However, matching search terms are now highlighted on each page too, making it easier to spot where words such as “apple” and “pie” appear and identify documents that might be worth exploring.

From my list of search results, the enhanced search filters helped me narrow the results down to books. Among the results was a recipe for apple custard pie from the Magic Cook Book, published in 1933.
Custard might not be the first thing to come to mind when you think of apple pie. But it was different enough to be intriguing while still fitting the original search for an apple recipe.
Once the recipe was found, the Canadiana beta platform also made it easy to download an image of the recipe page so I could reference it later. But the search result was only the beginning.
Exploring the Cookbook
One of the advantages of exploring the new Canadiana platform is that you don’t have to stop at the page where you find your search term. The Gallery view option in the new image viewer lets you see every page in a publication at-a-glance, while the Split view makes it possible to read one page in detail while exploring the surrounding pages as thumbnails. These view options allow you to easily navigate items and get a better sense of the publication as a whole.
In this case, browsing through the cookbook revealed plenty of other recipes worth trying, including one for a chopped pastry pie shell. It seemed like the perfect pairing for the apple custard filling.
With the recipes found, it was time to take them out of Canadiana and into the kitchen.
From Canadiana to the Kitchen
The apple custard filling was surprisingly simple to recreate.
The most unexpected instruction was “1 cup grated sweet apples.” Grating apples isn’t necessarily the first technique that comes to mind when making a pie, but it makes sense for a custard filling.
There was one detail the recipe left out: the oven temperature. The instructions simply say to “Bake 30 minutes.” Since ovens have changed considerably over the past century, 350°F seemed like a reasonable modern interpretation.
The pie was left to cool overnight before the big taste test.
The chopped pastry shell proved to be a little more challenging. Like many older recipes, the instructions were brief, leaving some details open to interpretation. I decided to partially blind bake the crust before adding the filling, since the custard mixture was quite liquid and I wanted to avoid a soggy bottom.
Unfortunately, the result was less than ideal. The pastry shell melted during the blind bake, leaving me with something that looked very different from the pie I had imagined.
So for this particular experiment, I turned to a modern solution: a ready-made pie shell from the grocery store. Making pastry from scratch was a challenge best left for another historical baking experiment.
With the new crust, the pie came together beautifully.

It was served at game night, where four people put the nearly century-old recipe to the test. The verdict? Two people loved it, myself included, while two decidedly did not like the texture of the grated apple.
A perfect 50/50 split.
Your Turn to Explore
What began as a simple search for “apple pie” ended with a nearly century-old recipe being recreated in a modern kitchen.
A new—old—recipe is just one example of what can turn up when exploring the Canadiana beta platform. The collections hold all kinds of material waiting to be discovered, and sometimes the most interesting finds are the ones you weren’t looking for in the first place.
Try starting with something you’re already curious about. Search for a person, place, ingredient, event, hobby, or even a word that makes you wonder what might be hiding in the collections. From there, follow the results and see where they lead.
The Canadiana beta platform offers a new way to explore Canadiana’s digitized collections, and it’s also an opportunity to help shape the experience by providing feedback. If you’re curious to learn more about the updates CRKN is making to Canadiana, see our announcement with the full details.
The question is now: What will you uncover?

Mélanie Plante (https://orcid.org/0009-0000-5563-3743)
Mélanie holds an Honours BA in English from the University of Ottawa. She joined CRKN in February 2024 and is passionate about Canadian literature.